From Archon Arcana - The KeyForge Wiki
Furtive Investors • Shadows • Action • Common • Play: If your opponent has more than you, gain 1 for each key your opponent has forged. • Artist: Fábio Perez • Card Number: AoA:269
No. Furtive Investor’s ability refers to the number of keys your opponent has forged currently.Source: Rulebook
In a previous turn, I played Key Hammer (COTA 066) to unforge my opponent’s first key, leaving them with zero keys currently forged. On my current turn, I play Furtive Investors (AOA 269). Do I get to gain an Æmber for the key they had forged but I unforged?
No. Furtive Investor’s ability refers to the number of keys your opponent has forged currently.